The Biden administration uses the January 6 attack on the Capitol Building as its justification for expanding the FBI's footprint.
The decision has significantly increased the number of agents assigned to โdomestic terrorism investigationsโ and their caseloadsโposing another round of government overreach in the name of national security.
Reason.com's Brian Dohertyย explainsย why FBI Director Christopher Wray's testimony on the subject before the Senate Committee on Homeland Security deserves greater scrutiny:
The events of January 6, Wray said, prove โa willingness by some to use violence against the government in furtherance of their political and social goals.โ Furthermore, โthe insular nature of their radicalization and mobilization to violence and limited discussions with others regarding their plans,โ Wray said, โincreases the challenge faced by law enforcement to detect and disrupt the activities of lone actors before they occur.โ
Of course,ย experience showsย us that when it comes to the FBI, โdetect and disruptโ often means โencourage and then arrestโ people who were no real threat until the FBI itself goaded them. Deciding beforehand that a set of people with certain beliefs inherently require more probing federal investigatory eyes all but guarantees a repeat of theย sort of harassment of Muslimsย in the U.S. that followed 9/11.
โฆ
Federal law enforcement officials and their allies oftenย fret about the lack in many casesย of specific โdomestic terrorismโ statutes that can be brought to bear when people commit certain crimes against a person or property. But in America, this is as it ought to be: Crimes against persons or property should be punished by law without worrying overmuch whether someone had a particular political thought or belief that motivated the crime.
Indeed, despite how the protests and Capitol breach on January 6 have been used as a prime example of a domestic terror threat and inspired Wray's anxieties, theย 650 arrestedย so far for their actions on that day have been charged just with the specific crimes they are alleged to have committed, without being formally characterized as domestic terror. For the 62ย who have pled guilty already, the majority pled to โParading, demonstrating, or picketing in a Capitol buildingโ (though at least 50 of the other arrestedย face chargesย related to violent assaults on officers). That the charges for January 6 involved what the accusedย didย and not what theyย believedย is the right approach.